• About
  • Resume
  • Rotch Summary
  • Vignettes
  • Blog

C KARLSON

An Architectural Journey

  • About
  • Resume
  • Rotch Summary
  • Vignettes
  • Blog

Case Study / Oslo Opera House

SIte - Oslo.jpg

In a moonlit scene of a storm-ravaged coast, Norwegian painter Knud Baade creates an operatic landscape of a mythical Norway inhabited by an antiquated warrior. It is a common view from a country that is considered at the crossroads to nowhere, off in a corner of Europe, dominated by the harshness of the Artic-like landscape. And yet, as the warrior stares at the moon-lit clouds standing rock-like as the cliff he stands on, it celebrates a symbiotic relationship between the perseverance of the Norwegian people and the unforgiving nature that surround them. It is an image that activates all the senses, enticing one to explore, to climb, to view out into the unknown; a divine experience to all that follow the journey. Enter 2008 and the opening of the new Oslo Opera House, a large glacial building that embodies the spirit of Baade's paintings, encouraging unrestricted exploratative motion and redefined perspectives while creating a new urban condition in the heart of Bjørvika Bay, a vast developing area in the center of Oslo.

Knud Baade’s 'Scene from the era of Norwegian Sagas', 1850 (from the private collection of Asbjørn Lunde)

Knud Baade’s 'Scene from the era of Norwegian Sagas', 1850 (from the private collection of Asbjørn Lunde)

IMG_0851.JPG
Le Corbusier's Villa Savoye (left) and the Oslo Opera House (right)

Le Corbusier's Villa Savoye (left) and the Oslo Opera House (right)

For centuries the Bjørvika pier has been one of Oslo’s economic lifelines and a point of contact with the rest of the world, however like so many other historic harbor cities, the site became underused and in a state of decay as harbor activity moved away from its central location. In 1999, after tireless political and cultural championing, the Norwegian Parliament decided that the Norwegian National Opera needed to move from its existing location in Anchor Square and construct a new opera house in Oslo. With the passage of the Opera Bill and much debate over different site possibilities, an open design competition was announced for the Bjorvika region that would bring in hundreds of design proposals, along with attracting an unprecedented amount of media attention and public interest. The international jury would declare the Norwegian design firm of Snøhetta the winner with a building concept based on three main elements: the Wave Wall, the Factory and the Carpet. The Wave Wall would develop into an extensive oak wall that composes a literal threshold between the public and private functions of the project, while The Factory represents the production area that would accommodate over 600 employees working in about 50 professions and trades for the new Opera House.

The final element, The Carpet, becomes the most obvious architectural characteristic with 190,000 sq.ft. of sloping marble roofscape growing out of the harbor’s waters. The defining element was specifically designed as common property - both a sculpted landscape and an topographic agora that allows free access for all and becomes a democratic source of experience that is independent of other theater functions. The pattern of the roof landscape, designated as artwork, is clad in a stone that traditionally has been used for public squares, sculpted as a jigsaw puzzle of tactile qualities that encourages movement through different visual perspectives and a heightened awareness of one’s surroundings. Ultimately, the sculpted roof exhibits the intention of the project, which is to return the location on which the opera house was constructed to the public and it’s natural surroundings. A quality rarely seen in civic design and one that ultimately speaks to Le Corbusier’s famous five points of architecture almost a century ago. Primarily used to illustrate the concept of domestic architecture as a standardized object, Le Corbusier’s theory emphasized the potential of restoring the area of ground covered by the house and bringing the landscape into the architecture with views and openness - blurring the relationship between built structure and the surrounding environment.

“The passing of the Opera Bill was not that popular at the time. It did not happen by popular demand. But then the building rises out of the dust, and people embrace it as if it was something they have yearned for! That is nothing short of a marvel and a conscious effort to showcase Norway as a cultural nation.”
— Anne Enger, former Minister of Culture
Map of Oslo  /  The central location of Opera House with primary access routes. Inner circle represents Bjørvika bay area surrounded by the outer circle of downtown Oslo. The black dot indicates the former location of the Norwegian Nationa…

Map of Oslo  /  The central location of Opera House with primary access routes. Inner circle represents Bjørvika bay area surrounded by the outer circle of downtown Oslo. The black dot indicates the former location of the Norwegian National Opera.

Bjørvika Bay from early 20th century. Red indicates location of future opera house.

Bjørvika Bay from early 20th century. Red indicates location of future opera house.

Bjørvika bay, perspective from Snøhetta's competition entry

Bjørvika bay, perspective from Snøhetta's competition entry

The conceptual elements of the opera building (The Wave, The Carpet, and The Factory), by Snøhetta

The conceptual elements of the opera building (The Wave, The Carpet, and The Factory), by Snøhetta

After the opening in 2008, the Oslo Opera House project was considered a success, both inside and outside, rising from the sea and linking the fjord to the city. The white platform rapidly became one of Oslo's most popular public properties, paired with the equally accessible Opera House foyer, granting visitors access to buy tickets for performances, eat in one of the restaurants, sit and enjoy a coffee, visit the Opera Shop or just stroll around and immerse yourself in the atmosphere. The openness and horizontality became the most evident characteristics of the project. However, once you leave the boundaries of the site, the building that prides itself on accessibility and free movement becomes increasingly marginalized in a undetermined context. Approaching the site from downtown Oslo today is like being transported through a cattle corral, leading visitors through restrictive enclosures toward greener pastures. Two pedestrian bridges, one from the north and the other from the west, lead visitors over a moat of networked roadways, only to land and encounter another footbridge spanning an excavated channel (Opera Canal) that seperates the Oslo Opera House from land. A series of events that would isolate a project, rather than accommodate within a city context.  

IMG_0890.JPG
IMG_5798.JPG
IMG_0925 3.jpg
IMG_0837 2.jpg
IMG_0907.jpg
IMG_0921 2.jpg
IMG_5461.jpg
IMG_6322-2.jpg
IMG_0862.jpg
Oslo-Opera-House_3-Revised.jpg

When the highly-debated Opera Bill was passed, it was understood that the Bjørvika site was only possible with a new traffic solution, as well as a more expensive building and the unclear surrounding ground conditions, making the price tag much higher ($840 million). The project would be formulated as a 'footprint master plan', making it independent from the planning of the rest of the urban development in that area (referred to as Fjord City) and of the complicated traffic situation. So, why choose to build an opera house dependent on a host of questionable considerations and for more money? The main motivation behind Bjørvika bay was to speed up urban development in the defunct region. The motto became "If you build it, they will come" and a few years after the Opera's completion, the surrounding area is slowly seeing progress. Recently, the Bjørvika Tunnel project (the first immersed tunnel in Norway) was completed, bypassing most car traffic along the waterfront and allowing the removal of the remaining E18 highway that separates the Oslo Opera House from the rest of the city.  

“This building has led to a discussion of the whole surrounding area, traffic, adjoining functions and the openness of the urban spaces. There has been a lot of discussion about how to make these areas as vibrant as possible; a discussion that demonstrates that public attention has really been alerted to the importance of urban development and public space.”
— Trond Giske, former Minister of Culture
View toward downtown Oslo showing the Opera House's main point of entry.

View toward downtown Oslo showing the Opera House's main point of entry.

The pedestrian footbridge to the north of the Opera

The pedestrian footbridge to the north of the Opera

The pedestrian footbridge to the west of the Opera

The pedestrian footbridge to the west of the Opera

Following local and international praise for the new Opera House and the completion of the Bjørvika Tunnel, the immediate area is undergoing a quick and sudden urban transformation. To the north of the Opera, a new commercial business district known as the Opera Quarter is currently under construction. Previously called 'the Bar Code' because of the long, slender plots of land and staggered heights of the buildings, the project will bring in the largest collection of living and working space in all of Oslo to the area (10,000 office spaces and 500 residences), creating a dense 24/7 live-work community focused on urban activity from the street level. To the south, the artificial peninsula of Sørengautstikkeren is starting construction on a redevelopment project that will include an entire new neighborhood of about 1,000 residential units. 

The 'Barcode Project' in Bjørvika

The 'Barcode Project' in Bjørvika

View looking south toward the artificial peninsula of Sørengautstikkeren (under construction)

View looking south toward the artificial peninsula of Sørengautstikkeren (under construction)

In 2008, the Norwegian Parliament decided to continue the growth of cultural influence in the Bjørvika region by initiating design competitions for both the Munch-Stenersen Museum and Oslo Public Library that would surround the Oslo Opera House, creating a new cultural epicenter in the city. To be located directly north of the Opera House, across from Opera Canal, the competition commitee awarded Lund Hagem Arkitekter the Oslo Public Library commission with an entry that focused on integrating the project into the city by dividing the site into three separate buildings, offering a subtle human scale and optimal views to the city. Directly next to the Opera's office wing on the east side of the site, the architectural firm of Herreros Arquitectos was awarded the commission for the Munch-Stenersen Museum as a high-rise project that is conceived as a highly visible 'place of concentration' for art and the community. Even Oslo's Central Train Station is joining the Bjørvika fray, by proposing a major redesign by Space Group that would focus on a new unified station sited on a linear north-south axis toward the Opera House, freeing up the ground level for public interaction and providing a massive roof garden above. Of course, to say all these projects were to continue forward as planned would be idealistic at best, as financial and political resistance is already prevalent, but it shows how a single successful project can generate enough public enthusiasm and political influence in a planned transformation of an entire area of the city. 

Masterplan of Bjørvika region around the Opera House

Masterplan of Bjørvika region around the Opera House

The proposal for the Oslo Public Library (left) north of the Oslo Opera House (right), design by Lund Hagem Arkitekter

The proposal for the Oslo Public Library (left) north of the Oslo Opera House (right), design by Lund Hagem Arkitekter

The proposal for the Munch/Stenersen Museum (left) next to the Oslo Opera House (right), design by Herreros Arquitectos

The proposal for the Munch/Stenersen Museum (left) next to the Oslo Opera House (right), design by Herreros Arquitectos

The proposal for the new Oslo Train Station, design by Space Group Architects

The proposal for the new Oslo Train Station, design by Space Group Architects

The Oslo Opera House can surely be seen as an invigorating urban presence in the quickly redeveloping Bjørvika district. A building designed not be noticed, but intended to actively engage urban dwellers - elevating them out of the city on an unprecedented civic device that is developed with Norwegian character. As one of Norway’s first opera houses (waiting 120 years to become reality) it surely has an attractive programmatic force that can direct attention, but it is that powerful integrated public landscape that has an ongoing dynamic relationship with the opera house that can transform an entire area - seen in such examples as New York’s High Line and Seattle’s Olympic Sculpture Park. The architecture becomes an activity rather than a singular object, able to entice human experiences of movement, conversation, performance, assembly and so much more. Like Baade’s warrior on the coastal rocks, one can stand on top the Opera’s glacial structure and experience their own transcendent journey.  

Diagram  /  Describing the current traffic conditions in Bjørvika. The red represents heavy car traffic that cuts off the Opera House from downtown Oslo, only by using two pedestrian bridges to cross (shown in blue). The new Bjørvika …

Diagram  /  Describing the current traffic conditions in Bjørvika. The red represents heavy car traffic that cuts off the Opera House from downtown Oslo, only by using two pedestrian bridges to cross (shown in blue). The new Bjørvika tunnel also shown.

“The building is not an icon. It’s trying to be the opposite. Because once you allow the public to move about the roof, it is they who generate the expression of the building, rather than the building itself.”
— Kjetil Trædal Thorsen, architect and co-founder of Snøhetta
Oslo Opera House  /   Site analysis of access, circulation, new development, and points of social engagement

Oslo Opera House  /   Site analysis of access, circulation, new development, and points of social engagement


tags: Rotch Research
categories: Norway, Rotch Case Studies
Friday 10.28.11
Posted by Christopher Karlson
 

The National Theater of Oslo

IMG_5529.jpg

Centrally located along a vast track of public space (Eidsvoll Square) between the Royal Palace grounds, the Norwegian Parliament and downtown Oslo - The National Theatre of Oslo was completed in 1899 under the watch of Norwegian architect Henrick Bull. The exterior expression is a combination of granite, limestone and brick (budget dicatating that stone only be used around the entry vestibules) that identifies with the historicism period in Scandinavia at the time. Today, the building is considered the prominent national venue for the dramatic arts - managing three stages for perfromances. 

National Theatre / Site Plan
National Theatre / Site Plan
National Theatre / Aerial
National Theatre / Aerial
Public square (Eidsvoll Square) adjacent to the National Theatre

Public square (Eidsvoll Square) adjacent to the National Theatre

North Elevation of the National Theatre

North Elevation of the National Theatre

Plaza west of the National Theatre

Plaza west of the National Theatre

Peacock Fountain outside the National Theatre

Peacock Fountain outside the National Theatre

Green corridor along Karl Johans Gate (Street)Aerial of Site

Green corridor along Karl Johans Gate (Street)Aerial of Site


tags: Rotch Research
categories: Norway
Thursday 10.20.11
Posted by Christopher Karlson
 

Norwegian Ambiguity / Architecture & Landscape

Sverre Fehn's Ivar Aasen Center in Ørsta

Sverre Fehn's Ivar Aasen Center in Ørsta

“Norwegian architecture can be connected to a particular relationship between building and landscape that can be described by the ambiguity between resistance and interplay. Both the larger landscape and the individual site can put up a fierce resistance to cultivation and construction. At the same time, terrain and vegetation offer rich possibilities for adding qualities to human building. Some woud say that this ambiguity, given by the meeting between man and landscape, is a given general expression in the Norwegian culture.”
— Ola Bettum, Landscape Architect
Village of Undredal along the Aurlandsfjord

Village of Undredal along the Aurlandsfjord

Village of Gudvangen located at the end of the Nærøyfjord

Village of Gudvangen located at the end of the Nærøyfjord

The Holmenkollbakken ski jump in the Holmenkollen neighborhood of Oslo

The Holmenkollbakken ski jump in the Holmenkollen neighborhood of Oslo

Aerial view of Ålesund

Aerial view of Ålesund

JSA's Mortensrud Church in Oslo

JSA's Mortensrud Church in Oslo

The Otternes Farmyard on the Sognefjord

The Otternes Farmyard on the Sognefjord

The village of Flåm at the inner end of the Aurlandsfjord

The village of Flåm at the inner end of the Aurlandsfjord

The village of Flåm at the inner end of the Aurlandsfjord

The village of Flåm at the inner end of the Aurlandsfjord

Steven Holl's Knut Hamsun Center in Hamarøy
Steven Holl's Knut Hamsun Center in Hamarøy
Steven Holl's Knut Hamsun Center in Hamarøy
Steven Holl's Knut Hamsun Center in Hamarøy
Steven Holl's Knut Hamsun Center in Hamarøy
Steven Holl's Knut Hamsun Center in Hamarøy
Steven Holl's Knut Hamsun Center in Hamarøy
Steven Holl's Knut Hamsun Center in Hamarøy

tags: Landscape
categories: Norway
Monday 10.17.11
Posted by Christopher Karlson
 

Context / Oslo, Norway

IMG_5880.JPG

Norway is a country dictated by the harsh expansive wilderness, spread over an area almost the size of Japan with a relatively low population of almost 5 million people. The area is deeply cut by the long, narrow inlets of fjords and dominated by a mountainous terrain containing some of the world's largest glaciers, making only 3% of the entire country arable for cultivation. Historically, Norway has been mired in poverty, dependent on the export of natural resources (fishing, whaling & timber), without developing urbanization, and in political subjection to it's Scandinavian neighbors. The Norwegian people, isolated and callous, worked through the impossible extremes of nature, developing a symbiotic relationship with the surrounding environment and created a nationalistic attitude for the future. By the end of the 19th century, Norway saw a new level of independence with the introduction of a parliamentary government leading to peaceful secession from Sweden in 1905. 

“The nature of Norway is nature untamed by cultivation. Here in Norway nature is the norm, whereas in many other places it is the cultivated land that people take for granted.”
— Sverre Fehn, Architect
A stave church near Oslo, dating back to the year 1200.

A stave church near Oslo, dating back to the year 1200.

The Viking ship, Oseberg, dating back to 834 AD

The Viking ship, Oseberg, dating back to 834 AD

Although considered small on the global spectrum, with a population of around one million people, the modern city of Oslo dominates the Norwegian landscape as the capital and most populous city in Norway. Without the grandeur of many larger European capitals, Oslo offers spacious park areas and forests, all within sight and sound of the sea, creating a level of connection to the surrounding context rarely seen in a modern city. Originally created as a fjord settlement during the Viking age, Oslo would not become a capital city until the 17th century, following a disastrous fire and while under Danish rule. The rebuilt capital city would be renamed Christiana, after the Danish King Christian IV, until 1905 when Norway broke with Sweden, reinstating the traditional name of Oslo twenty years later.  

View of tram line in front of Oslo Central Station and Jernbanetorget (The Railway Square)

View of tram line in front of Oslo Central Station and Jernbanetorget (The Railway Square)

Karl Johans Gate, Oslo's main street and pedestrian area

Karl Johans Gate, Oslo's main street and pedestrian area

New residential and commerical developments on Aker Brygge, an old industrial pier

New residential and commerical developments on Aker Brygge, an old industrial pier

Considered one of the most expensive cities in the world, Oslo has gone through a rapid modernization in the past 50 years. Building from a profitable timber trade of last century, Norway has invested heavily into the oil industry, developing a national wealth that has created the internationalization of Norwegian culture and a growing Norwegian self-confidence that has transformed Oslo into the fastest growing city in Europe. New cultural, residential and commercial development projects are now seen going up throughout the city, especially around the once diminishing harbor area. A chance for the once struggling nation to embrace recent financial success and intuitive contextural relationships, creating a new urban form.       

View of Oslo Harbour, Aker Brygge in the distance

View of Oslo Harbour, Aker Brygge in the distance

The Radhus (Oslo Town Hall) near Oslo Harbour

The Radhus (Oslo Town Hall) near Oslo Harbour


tags: City Context
categories: Norway, Rotch City Contexts
Monday 10.10.11
Posted by Christopher Karlson
 

All images © 2010-2020 Christopher Karlson